Artist Challenges

The Stuff of Legend Challenge
Spring 2024

We often refer to things as legendary but what does this actually mean? Legends are traditional stories thought to be based on historical events or figures but not authenticated. Unlike myths, which normally have a supernatural and/or sacred element in a timeless past, legends usually exist within a specific time historically and have a basis in fact. 

Your challenge is to create a piece of jewelry based on something that’s become the stuff of legends. This can include stories about events, people or places from around the world, things that have an historical basis from which legends have evolved. Here are a few examples to get you started.

Fire and Water fists hitting

King Arthur

It’s thought that behind the legendary figure of Arthur there is a real person, a great leader named Arturus. He was the champion who battled the Anglo-Saxons to support the Celtic Britons’ cause in the 5th century. Travelling Celtic bards recounted folk tales of the past and over time, Arturus, the military leader, became King Arthur of England. 

I won't be a rock star. I will be a legend.

Freddie Mercury 

Fire and Water fists hitting

Captain William Kidd

His fame in history comes more from the mystery of his hidden treasures than his actual exploits. Numerous stories have been told of where he buried his treasure, plundered from his time as a pirate. Over the years and despite generations of people looking for it, nothing has ever been found.

Sometimes legends make reality, and become more useful than the facts.

Salman Rushdie
Fire and Water fists hitting

Tintagel Castle, Cornwall

Thought to be the place where King Arthur was conceived, with the help of Merlin the magician.

The only way you can become a legend is in your coffin.

Bette Davis
Fire and Water fists hitting


Separating fact from legend in Sacagawea’s life is difficult; historians disagree on the dates of her birth and death and even on her name. She was a Shoshone Indian woman who, as interpreter, traveled thousands of miles in the wilderness with the Lewis and Clark Expedition (1804–06), from the Mandan-Hidatsa villages in the Dakotas to the Pacific Northwest.

History has its truth, and so has legend. Legendary truth is of another nature than historical truth. Legendary truth is invention whose result is reality. Furthermore, history and legend have the same goal; to depict eternal man beneath momentary man.

Victor Hugo
Fire and Water fists hitting


The ancient palace of Knossos, on the Greek island of Crete was a major city of the Minoan civilization. It is believed to have been the home of King Minos and his legendary Labyrinth, where he kept the Minotaur which featured prominently in Greek mythology. It is now one of the most famous archaeological sites in the world.

Now, I think that I should have known that he was magic all along. I did know it - but I should have guessed that it would be too much to ask to grow old with and see our children grow up together. So now, he is a legend when he would have preferred to be a man.

Jackie Kennedy
Fire and Water fists hitting

Robin Hood

Legend has it that Robin Hood was a skilled archer and swordsman. With a band of ‘merry men’, he fought the corrupt authority figures who oppressed the poor. He is known for stealing from the rich and giving the money to the poor. The existence of Robin Hood is just a story as far as historical record is concerned but references can be found to similar characters dating back to the 13th century.

The categories are:

  • Beginner
  • Intermediate
  • Advanced

Key Dates

March 1, 2024 – Submission for entries opens
April 5, 2024 – Submission closes for all entries
April 26, 2024 – Winners announced

Each category will have a winner and Certificate of Merit will also be awarded.

All winners get a digital certificate to use on their website and social media channels.

Jury’s comments
Artists tell us how affirming and inspiring the jury comments are, and how wonderful it is to receive feedback directly from some of the world’s top artists. After the winners are announced you’ll be able to log in to Artcall to view the jurors’ comments about the piece you submitted, these comments are private to you and not seen by anyone else.

Whatever skill level you believe you are, creating a piece for a challenge will boost your confidence as an artist. 

Plus – you’ll enjoy the inspiring private feedback you’ll get from the great artists of our jury! 

Interested in who won the previous challenges?

Check out the Winner’s Gallery


All prize packages are valued at over $500USD


50g Art Clay Silver 
(Sponsored by Art Clay World or Metal Clay Ltd)

PMC Decade (book)
(Sponsored by Brynmorgen Press)

Enameling on Copper DVD
(Sponsored by Pam East)

Selection of Fireable Gemstones
(Sponsor Anonymous)

Annual Subscription to Metal Clay Today
(Sponsored by Metal Clay Today)

Your choice of a 2-hour private consultation selected from a wide range of offerings from our AMCAW experts.

See the Expert Consultations page for more details.


50g Art Clay Silver
(Sponsored by Art Clay World or Metal Clay Ltd)

PMC Decade (book)
(Sponsored by Brynmorgen Press)

Enameling on Copper DVD
(Sponsored by Pam East)

Selection of Fireable Gemstones
(Sponsor Anonymous)

Annual Subscription to Metal Clay Today
(Sponsored by Metal Clay Today)

Your choice of a 2-hour private consultation selected from a wide range of offerings from our AMCAW experts.

See the Expert Consultations page for more details.


50g Art Clay 950 Silver
(Sponsored by Art Clay World or Metal Clay Ltd)

PMC Decade (book) 
(Sponsored by Brynmorgen Press)

Enameling on Copper DVD 
(Sponsored by Pam East)

100g Metal Adventures Fast Fire CopprClay
(Sponsor Anonymous)

100g Metal Adventures Fast Fire BronzClay
(Sponsor Anonymous)

Selection of Cabochons (non-fireable)
(Sponsor Anonymous)

Annual Subscription to Metal Clay Today
(Sponsored by Metal Clay Today)

Your choice of a 2-hour private consultation selected from a wide range of offerings from our AMCAW experts.

See the Expert Consultations page for more details.


Brynmorgen Press
pam east


Bronwyn Evans

Bronwyn Evan

Bronwyn is an AMCAW volunteer and metal clay artist.

Read more about her here…

Amy Tavern

Holly Cromwell

Holly is a metal clay artist focusing on one-of-a-kind designs.

Read more about her here…

Amy Tavern

Wendy Wallin Malinow

Wendy is an artist, designer, illustrator, and jeweler.

Find her on Facebook here

Artist Information

Please read the rules below carefully before creating your piece; we’ve also provided guidelines to help you select your category and prepare your entry.

Entries will be judged on the following criteria:

  • Design innovation and originality
  • Successful incorporation of materials
  • Quality of workmanship


There is no cost to enter the 2024 Stuff of Legend Challenge, you simply need to be a current member of AMCAW. All submissions will be checked against our member database before entry into the Challenge. Click here for more information about membership.

Key Dates

March 1, 2024 – Submission for entries opens
April 5, 2024 – Submission closes for all entries
April 26, 2024 – Winners announced

How to Enter

Please read the challenge terms and conditions for complete details on eligible submissions.

To enter this challenge you will need to create an account on Artcall. The button below will take you to the site where more details are available. If you have entered a previous challenge your Artcall login details will be the same for this one.

Photography Guide

Below are a range of images to help show what we will accept and what we will not. All of these photos were shot using a mobile phone camera and natural daylight only.

If you are struggling with photography, check out our blog posts Top 5 tools for taking great photos on a budget and Learn How To Edit Your Photos like a Pro

See Submission Guidelines below for more detail.

Piece shown clearly on white

Piece shown clearly on black

Piece shown clearly on background with slight shadow

Piece shown clearly with whole chain

Props detract from the piece

Too dark – piece can not be seen clearly

Out of focus – piece is blurry

Background too prominent

Submission Guidelines

How to Submit your Entry 

  • Submit one photograph of your piece following the rules for submitting photographs. 
  • Fill in the form that accompanies your photograph. 
  • Accept the terms and the privacy requirements. 

Rules on Submitting Photographs 

The only thing the jury will see when they are making their deliberations is the photograph of your submission. It is vitally important that your photograph represents your work in the very best way possible. Here are the rules for submitting your photographs: 

  • Use a high-quality photograph with a plain, black, graduated or white, smooth, uncluttered background and no additional props (plants, rocks, ring stands, busts etc.)
  • Do not show jewelry on a model or hold the piece in your hand
  • Jewelry must be complete and ready to wear. ie. pendant shown on a chain
  • Details of the piece should be clearly visible in the image
  • The photograph must be in focus and well lit
  • Images should be 300-dpi, JPEG format and no larger than 4MB
  • Only two photographs of the same piece may be entered per person
  • The second photograph should show detail not seen in the first photograph
  • Do not list your name, company name or logo or any other information that may identify you in your photograph

Information about your submission 

Each submission must include the following information: 

  • The category. 
  • The name of the piece. 
  • What the piece is – necklace, earrings, hair clip, etc. 
  • The dimensions of the piece. 
  • Type of metal clay used – fine silver, sterling silver, 960/950, bronze, copper etc. Do not include the brand. 
  • Other materials used – type of metal, stones, beads, other media etc.
  • Photographer credit if applicable.

Categories for Entry 

  • Beginners
  • Intermediate
  • Advanced

Entries will be judged on the following criteria:- 

  • Design innovation and originality. 
  • Successful incorporation of materials. 
  • Quality of workmanship. 

Key Dates 

March 1, 2024 – Submission for entries opens
April 5, 2024 – Submission closes for all entries
April 26, 2024 – Winners announced

Juror’s comments

After April 26, we will enable the juror’s comments on Artcall so the individual can view the comments about their entry. This information will only be available to the person who entered the piece by logging into their Artcall account and viewing their submission.

Challenge FAQs and things to clarify


Q:Who can enter, and who can’t?

A:Anyone can enter, including AMCAW board members, advisory board, and committee chairmen. You just need to become a member of AMCAW before entering and can join anytime right up to the entry deadline. Membership will be checked on the closing date to ensure the artist is still a current member. Entries for anyone with a lapsed membership will not be accepted.

Q:I can’t afford a professional photographer. How can I get a good image of my piece?

A:There are many free online tutorials about taking jewelry photographs; try Googling “taking jewelry photos” to find one. One key thing is lighting; it’s not all about the camera you’re using. Good images are possible with the newer phones, but you do need to use good lighting to get a clear picture and remember to save the image at the largest possible size.

Q:I can’t upload my image, it’s telling me the size is wrong. How do I resize my image?

A:There are a number of free image resizing programs online which can help. Try Googling “resize photos” or try one of these free sites:,, or If your computer uses Windows 10, your Paint application is also a good resource. Tip: It’s best to upload your photo a few days before the deadline so you can submit another photo if the first one isn’t sized correctly or is in the wrong format.

Q: I don’t understand the image size requirements. What is 1000px?

A: Px means pixels; your photo should be between 1000 pixels and 4000 pixels in size. Most photo resizing applications allow you to adjust the pixel size, as well as save it in a .jpeg format.

Q: Help! I think I’m a member of AMCAW but none of my emails or passwords are being recognized online.

A: Just send an email to and we will help you.

Q: Can I enter now and join AMCAW later?

A: You must log in using your AMCAW username and password to gain access to the challenge entry portal, so membership is required at the time of entry. In addition, all entries will be verified for membership on the challenge closing date.

Q: I always wait until the last minute! Can I enter on the last day?

A: Yes, but if anything is wrong with your entry, such as the photo, you won’t have time to resubmit it. Don’t risk it! We know time is always tight for artists, so go ahead and start the entry process with your basic information at your earliest convenience; your info will wait safely in the system until you’re ready to upload your photo.

Q: What happens if my piece is rejected for some reason – can I resubmit?

A: Yes.  If anything doesn’t meet the guidelines, you will be sent an email saying your entry has not been accepted, giving you details of why (for example, photo isn’t clear enough). Make sure the email you use to submit your piece(s) is one you monitor regularly as that is the only way we will contact you. Your piece will not be presented to the jury until you address the issue. You can correct and resubmit the piece but keep in mind that your resubmitted entry must be received by the deadline. You will not be able to change your submission image once the deadline has passed and in that case your piece will not be included in the jury process.

Q: The theme of this challenge is not for me. Will there be other challenges in the future?

A: Yes, we have two challenges a year. We have a number of other opportunities for members of AMCAW to get their work published – raising your profile not just in the metal clay community, but also in the wider metal working world.

Challenge rules
  1. This competition is only open to members of AMCAW. All submissions will be checked against our member database on the date the Challenge closes, April 25, 2024 (midnight GMT), before entry into the Challenge. Submissions from non-members or members whose membership has lapsed will not be accepted or acknowledged. 
  2. There are three categories of entry defined by the skill level the maker has in working with metal clay. Members should submit their work in the category they feel most accurately represents their experience with metal clay. The jury reserves the right to reclassify the category of an entry.
  3. Please read the submission and photograph guidelines carefully and ensure you follow them. Submissions which do not follow the guidelines will not be accepted and you will be informed that your entry is not in an acceptable format. You may resubmit the entry using the correct format before the deadline, so it’s to your advantage to enter the Challenge early.
  4. Members can submit up to three entries, but each entry must be submitted separately and must follow the submission guidelines.
  5. The Artcall system does not allow you to enter anything after the deadline. This includes anything that is rejected and requires resubmission.
  6. All entries must be the work of the AMCAW member submitting it, and must be a unique and original design.
  7. All entries must use metal clay in part or in full. Mixed media work is acceptable, but the entry should use metal clay as a significant element in the design.
  8. Entries can be jewelry or bodily adornment only. 
  9. The jury will be looking for design innovation and originality, successful incorporation of materials and quality of workmanship.
  10. Photographs should be high resolution, between 1,000 and 4,000 pixels, in .jpeg format, and no larger than 4 MB.
  11. The jury will evaluate each entry anonymously – in other words, without knowing the name of the member who submitted it. Do not show your name, company name, logo, website or social media links or any other information that may identify you, in your photograph(s), the materials used, the name of the piece or in the text for what inspired you to make the piece. Personal details must only be entered in the user profile area of your ArtCall account.
  12. When you enter a piece in this challenge, you agree to AMCAW using the image of your piece in publicity, sharing your name and image with our sponsors – who may use it in their publicity – sharing it with other members of AMCAW and the general public. AMCAW reserves the right to use the image on their website, in their advertising and on social media. By entering this challenge, you are agreeing to these conditions.
  13. All shipping, import tax, duty and handling charges for prizes sent will be paid by AMCAW. Duty, tax, etc., may need to be paid by the recipient (depending on your local tax and import rules) but AMCAW will reimburse you upon receiving official receipts for payment.
  14. Expert Consultations must be completed within six months of the winner being notified. AMCAW reserves the right to withdraw this prize
    if the winner does not finalise the details and dates with their chosen expert within six months.
  15. The decision of the jury is final.
  16. Winners will be notified by email.